The door to Smuggler's Cove, the San Francisco tiki cocktail bar with more than 1,300 rums behind it, is black, windowless and marked with nothing but the number 650, set into an aqua wall on a Hayes Valley block that David Wondrich once called one of the dullest in the city. Open it and the block is gone: three floors for 49 people, an indoor waterfall, and a bar that spent six straight years on the World's 50 Best Bars list (peaking at No. 16 in 2014) and in 2026 was a James Beard Award nominee for Outstanding Bar.
A Photo for a Résumé
In 1994 a co-worker in Washington, DC took Martin Cate to the Trader Vic's in the basement of the Hilton, promising drinks "as big as your head," on what Cate remembers as "a November night, and it was drizzly and cold." He told MUNCHIES he didn't "get" it, but he loved being somewhere warm and twilight-lit that let him forget everything else. Four years later, after a tiki party, he and his wife Rebecca built a home bar out of the leftover gear and called it the Novato Grotto, and when he applied to bartend at Trader Vic's in San Francisco, the Grotto was his résumé: "I quite literally brought him a printed color photo of my home tiki bar as my resume," and after pondering it a while the manager said, "I can work with this. You're hired."
It was, by Cate's own account, his only real bartending job, and he was "a duffer" at it. He opened Forbidden Island in Alameda in 2006 with partners (they brought the dough, he brought the tiki), left in 2009, and that June announced Smuggler's Cove with an online treasure-map game that handed out clues to the address. The building had been Jade Bar, and San Francisco's cap on liquor licenses made it a lucky find: "It was a year before I saw one for sale again." Smuggler's Cove opened December 8, 2009, with a press release that reads like a score being settled: "Too often, people associate rum with syrupy and artificial drinks and we're here to change that."
Three Floors Below Deck
The ground floor is the inside of a ship, wood-slat walls made to look like a hull, heavy beams, thick rope, a figurehead and a full-size anchor tied across the ceiling, all lit by ship lamps, glass fishing floats and glowing blowfish, and with no windows there is nothing to tell you you're on Gough Street. The designer was Ignacio "Notch" Gonzalez, a hot-rod builder with a "heavy sideline in tiki artifacts." Upstairs, the loft has grass-hut walls, leather banquettes and tables built like rum crates stenciled "DEMERARA RUM" and "HECHO EN CUBA." Follow the waterfall down a flight to the Boathouse, a low-ceilinged second bar where the harpoons on the wall came from the original Trader Vic's in Emeryville.
Readers of Moby-Dick will think of Melville's Spouter-Inn, whose walls are hung with "monstrous clubs and spears" and rusty "whaling lances and harpoons," around a bar that is "a rude attempt at a right whale's head." Smuggler's Cove has carved clubs in the loft and harpoons in the basement, which makes the comparison tempting and slightly unfair to Melville, whose harpoons came home from whales; these came home from Emeryville. Cate takes that lineage seriously: calling tiki "just a good time," he told the New York Times, is "as crazy as walking into the Guggenheim and declaring it to be Art Nouveau." The speakers play Hawaiian ukulele, bossa nova, surf and exotica, and the menu asks you to respect the neighbors "by exiting the cove quietly."

What to Drink at Smuggler's Cove
Cate came to rum through the Zombie, which at home meant buying four rums for $200, so his pitch to customers is arithmetic: "you could make the Zombie at home, but here's the shopping list. Why don't you come here instead? I've got a thatched roof and we'll do the dishes." The menu runs to more than 80 drinks, laid out like a syllabus from Rum Through The Ages to Exotic Cocktails Without (Gasp!) Rum, and nothing on it is batched, so the drinks with eight to 12 ingredients get built one at a time, with a diamond beside the ones the bar calls Very Strong. Start with the Mai Tai ($17), five ingredients and no diamond: rum, fresh lime, house-made orgeat, orange curaçao, demerara sugar. Cate's own Dead Reckoning ($18) is rum, pineapple, fresh lemon, vanilla liqueur, maple, tawny port, angostura bitters. The Zombie ($21) gets its diamond and reads rums, fresh lime, fresh grapefruit, fresh brains, island spices, herbsaint. Cate says the Three Dots and a Dash ($17), rums, fresh lime, fresh orange, honey, falernum, allspice and bitters, "does a really good job telling the story of tiki in one drink." The Painkiller is priced by nerve, $17 for two ounces of rum up to $19 for four, the new Flotsam Fizz ($25) arrives in a crate mug that goes home with you, and non-drinkers can name a few flavors and get a drink built around them for $13.
The homework comes with the Rumbustion Society, the bar's free rum club, which starts with 20 tastes signed off by a bartender and a quiz, puts your name on the wall at 80 rums, and at 300 in total ends with a distillery visit with Cate himself. Some members have gone on to 600 rums, so the bar added levels. Of the society's events, the general manager told the Examiner: "It's not for Instagram."

Getting Past the Doorman
Smuggler's Cove doesn't take reservations, so on busy nights the evening starts on the sidewalk, where a doorman runs a first-come line and counts heads, and once the bar hits 49, someone has to leave before the next person goes in; the FAQ adds that a friend who shows up an hour late doesn't get to skip ahead. Everyone needs ID, and nobody under 21 gets in, babies included, not even to use the restroom. There's no food. Cate's book, written with Rebecca, won a James Beard Award in 2017 and is sold at the bar, signed, for $32.99. See our guide to San Francisco tiki bars and our review of the Tonga Room, where it rains indoors. Regulars report lines forming before the 5pm opening on Saturdays, say the bar stools are the seats to want, and mention that the door staff will recommend a drink while you wait.
Photos: Smuggler's Cove, BanjoZebra / Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 4.0), Smuggler's Cove










